| 2019 Region 6A | | | |
| Emma Bailey (1st Team) | Haley Coyle (1st Team) | Payton O’Connor (1st Team) | Rylee Reeves (1st Team) |
| 2018 Region 6A | | | |
| Emma Bailey (1st Team) | Melanie Bennett (1st Team) | Melanie Bennett (Pitcher of the Yr) | Daisy Hess (1st Team) |
| Payton O’Connor (1st Team) | Rylee Reeves (1st Team) | | |
| 2017 Region 6A | | | |
| Melanie Bennett (1st Team) | Daisy Hess (1st Team) | Kaitlin Isley (1st Team) | Nicolle Nysted (1st Team) |
| Shea Reagor (1st Team) | Ari Wright (1st Team) | | |
| 2016 Region 6A | | | |
| Daisy Hess (1st Team) | Maggie Lewis (1st Team) | Nicolle Nysted (1st Team) | Darby Pinkard (1st Team) |
| 2015 Region 5A | | | |
| Madison Halyard (1st Team) | Maggie Lewis (1st Team) | Hailey Reagor (1st Team) | Daisy Hess (2nd Team) |
| Darby Pinkard (2nd Team) | Grace Wilcox (2nd Team) | | |
| 2014 Region 5A | | | |
| Bailey Crawford (1st Team) | Kara Hester (1st Team) | Morgan Kazerooni (1st Team) | Casey Lewis (1st Team) |
| Hailey Reagor (1st Team) | Makenzie Colwart (2nd Team) | | |
| 2013 Region 5A | | | |
| Elisabeth Federici (1st Team) | Makenzie Colwart (1st Team) | Dani Lewis (1st Team) | Morgan Kazerooni (1st Team) |
| Casey Lewis (2nd Team) | Hailey Reagor (2nd Team) | Madisyn Escue (2nd Team) | Nicole Williams (2nd Team) |
| 2012 Region 5A | | | |
| Bailey Crawford (1st Team) | Madisyn Escue (1st Team) | Jessica Finch (1st Team) | Erika Dunbar (2nd Team) |
| 2011 Region 7A | | | |
| Kara Chambers (1st Team) | Jessica Finch (1st Team) | Tressa Watson 7A (1st Team) | Erika Dunbar 7A (2nd Team) |
| 2010 Region 7A | | | |
| Kara Chambers (1st Team) | Jessica Finch (1st Team) | Caitlin O’Shea (1st Team) | Megan Nesbit (1st Team) |
| 2009 Region 7A | | | |
| Kara Chambers (1st Team) | Megan Nesbit (1st Team) | Caitlin O’Shea (1st Team) | |
| 2008 Region 7A | | | |
| Malorie Pivato (Tourn. Team) | | | |